Auto Insurance and Credit in Canada: The Score Connection
How Your Credit Score Connects to Auto Insurance in Canada
For many Canadians, the idea that their credit score could affect their car insurance premiums seems unfair — or even surprising. After all, what does your history of repaying debts have to do with how safely you drive? Yet in several Canadian provinces, insurers are permitted to use credit information as one factor in determining your auto insurance rates. If you have bad credit, this can mean paying hundreds of dollars more per year for the same coverage as someone with a higher score.
This guide will explain everything you need to know about the connection between your credit score and auto insurance in Canada. We will cover which provinces allow credit-based insurance pricing, how insurers actually use your credit data, strategies for getting affordable coverage with bad credit, and practical steps to improve your situation over time.
Credit-based insurance scoring is permitted in some Canadian provinces for private auto insurance but is prohibited in provinces with public auto insurance systems (British Columbia, Saskatchewan, Manitoba, and Quebec). Even where allowed, your credit score is just one of many factors affecting your premium — and it cannot be used to deny you coverage outright.
Understanding Credit-Based Insurance Scoring
Credit-based insurance scoring is different from a traditional credit score. While your Equifax or TransUnion credit score (typically ranging from 300 to 900 in Canada) is designed to predict the likelihood that you will repay a debt, an insurance score is designed to predict the likelihood that you will file an insurance claim.
What Is an Insurance Score?
An insurance score is a numerical rating that insurers calculate using data from your credit report, combined with other factors, to assess your risk as a policyholder. Insurance scores typically consider:
- Payment history: How consistently you pay your bills on time
- Outstanding debt: How much you currently owe relative to your available credit
- Credit history length: How long you have had credit accounts
- Credit mix: The types of credit you use (credit cards, loans, lines of credit)
- Recent credit inquiries: How many new credit applications you have made recently
Importantly, insurance scores do not consider:
- Your income or employment status
- Your race, ethnicity, religion, or gender
- Your marital status (though some provinces allow this separately)
- Where you bank
- Any information not found on your credit report
How Insurance Scores Differ From Credit Scores
| Feature | Credit Score (Equifax/TransUnion) | Insurance Score |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Predicts likelihood of debt repayment | Predicts likelihood of filing an insurance claim |
| Score Range | 300 – 900 | Varies by insurer (often 200 – 997) |
| Who Uses It | Lenders, landlords, some employers | Insurance companies (where permitted) |
| Factors Weighted Most | Payment history, credit utilization | Payment history, outstanding debt, length of history |
| Type of Inquiry | Can be hard or soft pull | Typically soft pull (no impact on credit score) |
| Transparency | You can access your score | Insurers generally do not share your insurance score |
One important distinction: when an insurer checks your credit for insurance purposes, it is almost always a soft inquiry. This means it will NOT appear on your credit report and will NOT lower your credit score. You do not need to worry that shopping for auto insurance quotes will damage your credit.
Which Canadian Provinces Allow Credit-Based Insurance Pricing?
Canada has a patchwork of auto insurance systems. Some provinces operate public auto insurance monopolies, while others have fully private or mixed systems. The rules around credit-based insurance scoring vary accordingly.
Provinces With Public Auto Insurance
Four provinces operate government-run auto insurance systems where credit scores are not used in premium calculations:
| Province | Public Insurer | Credit Used for Pricing? | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| British Columbia | ICBC (Insurance Corporation of BC) | No | Basic insurance is mandatory through ICBC; optional coverage available from private insurers |
| Saskatchewan | SGI (Saskatchewan Government Insurance) | No | Basic coverage through SGI; extension coverage available privately |
| Manitoba | MPI (Manitoba Public Insurance) | No | All basic auto insurance through MPI |
| Quebec | SAAQ (Société de l’assurance automobile du Québec) | No | SAAQ covers bodily injury; private insurers cover property damage but generally do not use credit |
If you live in British Columbia, Saskatchewan, Manitoba, or Quebec, your credit score does NOT affect your basic auto insurance premiums. These provinces use government-run systems that base premiums on factors like driving record, vehicle type, and location — not credit history.
Provinces With Private Auto Insurance
In provinces with private auto insurance systems, insurers may use credit-based insurance scoring as part of their underwriting process:
| Province | Insurance System | Credit-Based Scoring | Regulatory Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ontario | Private (regulated) | Permitted with consent | Regulated by FSRA; ongoing debate about restricting use |
| Alberta | Private (regulated) | Permitted with consent | Regulated by Alberta Superintendent of Insurance |
| Nova Scotia | Private (regulated) | Permitted with consent | Regulated by NS Superintendent of Insurance |
| New Brunswick | Private (regulated) | Permitted with consent | Regulated by FCNB |
| Prince Edward Island | Private (regulated) | Permitted with consent | Limited regulatory guidance |
| Newfoundland and Labrador | Private (regulated) | Permitted with consent | Regulated by provincial superintendent |
Consent Requirements
In all provinces where credit-based insurance scoring is permitted, insurers must obtain your explicit consent before accessing your credit information. Under PIPEDA (the Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act), you have the right to:
- Know that your credit is being checked
- Consent to or refuse the credit check
- Ask what credit information was used and how it affected your premium
“Consumers should understand that they have the right to ask their insurer whether credit information was used in their premium calculation and, if so, how it affected their rate. Transparency is a fundamental principle of Canadian insurance regulation.” — Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions
What Happens If You Refuse a Credit Check?
If you decline to allow an insurer to check your credit, they cannot force you. However, the consequences vary:
- Some insurers will simply calculate your premium without the credit component, which may or may not be higher
- Others may assign you a “neutral” or “average” credit tier, which could result in a higher premium than you would get with good credit but lower than you would get with bad credit
- A few insurers may decline to offer you a quote altogether, though this is uncommon
How Much Does Credit Actually Affect Auto Insurance Premiums?
The impact of credit on auto insurance premiums varies by insurer, but the difference can be substantial. Here is a general illustration of how credit can affect annual auto insurance costs in a province like Ontario or Alberta:
| Credit Tier | Credit Score Range | Estimated Annual Premium (Average Driver) | Premium Difference vs. Excellent |
|---|---|---|---|
| Excellent | 800+ | $1,400 – $1,800 | Baseline |
| Very Good | 750 – 799 | $1,500 – $1,950 | +5% to +8% |
| Good | 700 – 749 | $1,600 – $2,100 | +10% to +15% |
| Fair | 650 – 699 | $1,800 – $2,400 | +20% to +30% |
| Poor | 600 – 649 | $2,100 – $2,900 | +35% to +50% |
| Very Poor | Below 600 | $2,500 – $3,600 | +50% to +100% |
Credit Is Just One Factor
It is important to understand that credit is just one of many factors that insurers use to calculate premiums. Other factors typically carry more weight, including:
- Driving record: At-fault accidents, traffic violations, and convictions
- Location: Where you live and where your car is parked
- Vehicle type: Make, model, year, and safety features
- Annual mileage: How much you drive each year
- Age and driving experience: Newer drivers typically pay more
- Claims history: Previous insurance claims, regardless of fault
- Coverage levels: The types and amounts of coverage you choose
- Deductible: Higher deductibles lower premiums
Getting Auto Insurance With Bad Credit: Practical Strategies
If you have bad credit and need auto insurance, do not despair. There are numerous strategies you can use to find affordable coverage, even if your credit is not perfect.
-
Strategy 1: Shop Around Extensively||Different insurers weigh credit differently in their pricing models. Some may place heavy emphasis on credit scores, while others give it minimal weight. Get quotes from at least five to seven different insurers or use an insurance broker who can shop multiple companies at once. The difference between the cheapest and most expensive quote can be 50% or more.
-
Strategy 2: Work With an Insurance Broker||Unlike agents who represent a single company, brokers work with multiple insurers and can find the best rate for your specific situation. They have experience placing policies for clients with poor credit and know which companies are most flexible. Broker services are typically free to you — they earn their commission from the insurer.
-
Strategy 3: Consider Usage-Based Insurance (UBI)||Many Canadian insurers now offer telematics or usage-based insurance programs that track your driving behaviour through a smartphone app or plug-in device. If you are a safe driver, your good driving habits can offset the impact of poor credit on your premium. Programs like Intact’s my Drive, Aviva’s Driving Less, and Desjardins’ Ajusto can save you 10–25%.
-
Strategy 4: Increase Your Deductible||Raising your deductible from $500 to $1,000 or $2,000 can reduce your premium by 15–30%. Just make sure you have enough savings to cover the higher deductible if you need to make a claim.
-
Strategy 5: Bundle Your Policies||Many insurers offer multi-policy discounts of 5–15% when you bundle auto insurance with home, renters, or other types of insurance. Even if each individual policy costs more due to your credit, the bundle discount can offset some of that cost.
-
Strategy 6: Reduce Your Coverage (If Appropriate)||If you drive an older vehicle with low market value, you may want to consider dropping comprehensive and collision coverage and keeping only the legally required liability coverage. This can significantly reduce your premium, though it means you would pay out of pocket if your vehicle is damaged or stolen.
-
Strategy 7: Take a Driving Course||Completing an approved driver training course can qualify you for a discount of 5–10% with many insurers. This is especially beneficial for new drivers or those returning to driving after a break.
The Debate: Should Credit Be Used in Insurance Pricing?
The use of credit scores in auto insurance pricing is one of the most debated topics in Canadian insurance regulation. There are strong arguments on both sides.
Arguments in Favour of Credit-Based Scoring
Statistical Correlation: Insurance industry research shows a statistically significant correlation between poor credit and higher claims frequency. Insurers argue that credit-based scoring allows them to price risk more accurately.
Lower Premiums for Good Credit: Supporters argue that credit-based scoring benefits the majority of consumers by allowing insurers to offer lower premiums to lower-risk policyholders.
Actuarial Fairness: The insurance industry argues that using all available data to assess risk leads to fairer, more accurate pricing for everyone.
Arguments Against Credit-Based Scoring
Disproportionate Impact: Critics argue that credit-based scoring disproportionately affects lower-income Canadians, recent immigrants, young people, and those who have experienced financial hardship due to divorce, medical emergencies, or job loss.
Correlation vs. Causation: Having bad credit does not cause someone to drive recklessly. The correlation may simply reflect the fact that people facing financial stress are more likely to both have poor credit and file claims (e.g., deferred vehicle maintenance leading to breakdowns).
Redundancy: Many of the risk factors captured by credit scores are already reflected in other rating factors, such as claims history and driving record.
Systemic Inequity: Consumer advocacy groups argue that credit-based scoring perpetuates a cycle where financially disadvantaged people pay more for insurance, leaving less money to improve their credit — a vicious circle.
“Using credit scores to set insurance premiums is fundamentally unfair. It punishes people who are already struggling financially and creates a two-tier system where those who can least afford higher premiums are the ones who pay them. We need regulatory reform to address this inequity.” — Canadian Consumer Advocacy Organization
Legislative and Regulatory Developments
The regulatory landscape around credit-based insurance scoring in Canada is evolving:
- Ontario: There have been ongoing discussions at FSRA (Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario) about whether to restrict or ban credit-based insurance scoring. Several consumer groups have submitted formal requests for rule changes.
- Alberta: The province has considered reforms to auto insurance pricing, including reviewing the role of credit scores. No ban has been implemented as of 2026.
- Newfoundland and Labrador: The province conducted a review of auto insurance rating factors in recent years, with credit scoring being one of the topics examined.
- Federal Level: Some Members of Parliament have raised the issue of credit-based insurance scoring as a consumer protection concern, though no federal legislation has been introduced.
How Insurers Actually Use Your Credit Data
Understanding the mechanics of how insurers use credit data can help you make more informed decisions. Here is a behind-the-scenes look at the process.
The Underwriting Process
When you apply for auto insurance in a province where credit-based scoring is permitted, here is what typically happens:
- You provide your consent for the insurer to access your credit information
- The insurer sends a request to Equifax or TransUnion for your credit data
- The credit bureau returns a soft-pull summary of your credit profile (this does not affect your credit score)
- The insurer’s proprietary algorithm processes the credit data along with other rating factors
- Your insurance score is calculated and placed into a rating tier
- The tier, combined with all other factors, determines your final premium
What Credit Data Matters Most for Insurance
While each insurer has its own proprietary algorithm, research suggests that the following credit factors have the greatest influence on insurance scores:
| Credit Factor | Relative Impact on Insurance Score | Why It Matters to Insurers |
|---|---|---|
| Payment history | Very High | Consistent bill payment suggests responsible behaviour |
| Outstanding debt-to-credit ratio | High | High utilization may indicate financial stress |
| Length of credit history | Moderate | Longer history provides more predictive data |
| Number of recent inquiries | Low to Moderate | Multiple applications may indicate financial instability |
| Types of credit used | Low | Diverse credit mix suggests financial sophistication |
| Collections or bankruptcies | Very High (negative) | Indicates serious financial difficulties |
If you have a bankruptcy or consumer proposal on your credit report, this will likely have the most significant impact on your insurance score. However, many insurers will still offer you coverage — the premium will simply reflect the higher perceived risk. As the bankruptcy ages and your credit improves, your insurance premiums should decrease accordingly.
Auto Insurance After Bankruptcy or Consumer Proposal
If you have recently gone through a bankruptcy or filed a consumer proposal, you may be particularly concerned about your auto insurance. Here is what you need to know.
Can You Get Auto Insurance After Bankruptcy?
Yes, absolutely. No insurer in Canada can legally refuse to provide you with the legally required minimum auto insurance coverage based solely on a bankruptcy. In provinces with public insurance (BC, Saskatchewan, Manitoba, Quebec), bankruptcy has no effect on your ability to get basic coverage.
In provinces with private insurance, bankruptcy may result in higher premiums, but you can still get coverage. If you are having difficulty finding affordable insurance after a bankruptcy, consider:
- Working with a high-risk insurance broker who specializes in non-standard markets
- Checking with the Facility Association (a last-resort insurer pool that ensures all Canadian drivers can get coverage)
- Asking your Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT) for referrals to insurance brokers who work with post-bankruptcy clients
The Facility Association: Insurance of Last Resort
The Facility Association is an industry organization that operates in provinces with private auto insurance. Its purpose is to ensure that every Canadian driver can obtain the legally required auto insurance, even if no insurer in the standard market is willing to provide coverage.
If you are unable to find auto insurance through regular channels (due to poor credit, a bad driving record, or other risk factors), a broker can apply to the Facility Association on your behalf. Coverage through the Facility Association is typically more expensive than standard market insurance, but it guarantees that you will not be left without legally required coverage.
The Facility Association is a safety net, not a penalty. Every Canadian driver is entitled to at least basic auto insurance coverage. If you are struggling to find coverage due to bad credit, a broker can access the Facility Association to ensure you can legally drive.
Improving Your Credit to Lower Your Auto Insurance Premiums
If you live in a province where credit affects insurance premiums, improving your credit score is one of the most effective ways to reduce your auto insurance costs over time. Here are actionable steps you can take.
Short-Term Strategies (1–6 Months)
- Pay all bills on time: Set up automatic payments or reminders to ensure you never miss a due date. Payment history is the most heavily weighted factor in both credit scores and insurance scores.
- Reduce credit card balances: Aim to keep your credit utilization below 30% of your available credit. If possible, pay down balances to below 10% for maximum benefit.
- Dispute errors on your credit report: Check your Equifax and TransUnion reports for errors. Incorrect late payments, wrong balances, or accounts that are not yours can drag down your score. Dispute any errors through the credit bureau’s online portal.
- Avoid new credit applications: Each hard inquiry can temporarily lower your score. If you are trying to improve your credit for insurance purposes, avoid applying for new credit cards or loans unless absolutely necessary.
Medium-Term Strategies (6–18 Months)
- Get a secured credit card: If you have very poor credit, a secured credit card can help you build a positive payment history. Use it for small purchases and pay the balance in full each month.
- Become an authorized user: If a family member with good credit adds you as an authorized user on their credit card, their positive payment history may help boost your score.
- Consider a credit-builder loan: Some financial institutions offer small loans specifically designed to help build credit. The loan amount is held in a savings account while you make payments, and when the loan is paid off, you receive the funds.
Long-Term Strategies (18+ Months)
- Maintain a diverse credit mix: Having a combination of credit types (credit card, installment loan, line of credit) can positively impact your score over time.
- Keep old accounts open: The length of your credit history matters. Keep your oldest credit accounts open and in good standing, even if you rarely use them.
- Practice consistent financial management: Over time, consistent responsible financial behaviour will raise your credit score. Most negative items fall off your report after six to seven years.
Province-by-Province Auto Insurance Guide for Drivers With Bad Credit
Here is a brief overview of the auto insurance landscape for drivers with bad credit in each region of Canada.
Ontario
Ontario has the highest average auto insurance premiums in Canada. Credit-based scoring is permitted, which means bad credit can compound an already expensive situation. Drivers in the Greater Toronto Area (GTA) pay the most. Strategies for Ontario drivers include using telematics programs, taking advantage of group insurance discounts through employers or professional associations, and shopping aggressively for quotes.
Alberta
Alberta uses a private insurance system where credit can be a factor. The province has experienced significant premium increases in recent years. Alberta drivers with bad credit should consider increasing their deductibles, using telematics programs, and working with brokers who specialize in non-standard markets.
Atlantic Provinces (Nova Scotia, New Brunswick, PEI, Newfoundland and Labrador)
The Atlantic provinces generally have lower auto insurance premiums than Ontario or Alberta. Credit-based scoring is permitted but may have less dramatic impact due to lower base rates. Drivers in these provinces may find more affordable options, especially through regional insurers and co-operatives.
British Columbia
ICBC provides basic auto insurance without credit checks. Optional coverage from private insurers may involve a credit assessment, but the mandatory portion of your coverage is credit-blind. BC drivers with bad credit are well-served by the public system.
Saskatchewan and Manitoba
Both provinces operate public auto insurance systems that do not use credit scores. Drivers in these provinces benefit from credit-blind pricing for basic coverage.
Quebec
Quebec’s hybrid system (SAAQ for bodily injury, private insurers for property damage) generally does not use credit in pricing. Quebec drivers with bad credit are unlikely to see significant premium impacts.
Comparing Auto Insurance Quotes: A Practical Approach
When shopping for auto insurance with bad credit, a systematic approach will help you find the best deal. Here is how to compare quotes effectively.
What Information You Will Need
Before getting quotes, gather the following information:
- Your driver’s licence number
- Vehicle identification number (VIN)
- Current odometer reading and estimated annual kilometres
- Details of any accidents, tickets, or claims in the past six to ten years
- Names and licence numbers of any other drivers in your household
- Your current insurance policy details (if applicable)
Where to Get Quotes
| Source | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Direct insurers (e.g., Belair, Sonnet, Onlia) | Often lower prices due to no broker fees; easy online quotes | Limited to one company’s products |
| Insurance brokers | Access to multiple companies; expert advice; advocacy during claims | May have limited digital tools |
| Comparison websites (e.g., LowestRates.ca, InsuranceHotline.com) | Quick comparison of multiple quotes; free to use | May not include all insurers; quotes are estimates |
| Group insurance programs | Discounted rates through employers, alumni associations, or professional groups | Limited availability; must belong to the group |
Join 10,000+ Canadians who started their credit journey with Credit Resources.
GET STARTED NOWFrequently Asked Questions About Auto Insurance and Credit in Canada
Q: Does checking my credit for auto insurance lower my credit score?
A: No. Insurance credit checks are soft inquiries that do not appear on your credit report and do not affect your credit score. You can get as many auto insurance quotes as you want without worrying about any impact on your credit.
Q: Can I be denied auto insurance because of bad credit?
A: No. In Canada, you cannot be denied the legally required minimum auto insurance coverage because of your credit score. However, bad credit may result in higher premiums in provinces where credit-based scoring is permitted. If no standard insurer will offer you a policy, the Facility Association ensures you can still get coverage.
Q: Which provinces do not use credit for auto insurance?
A: British Columbia (ICBC), Saskatchewan (SGI), Manitoba (MPI), and Quebec (SAAQ) operate public auto insurance systems that do not use credit scores to determine premiums.
Q: How much more will I pay for auto insurance with bad credit?
A: The impact varies by insurer and province, but drivers with poor credit scores (below 600) can pay 50% to 100% more than drivers with excellent credit (800+) for comparable coverage. This can translate to $700–$1,800 more per year.
Q: Can I refuse to let my insurer check my credit?
A: Yes, you have the right to refuse a credit check. However, the insurer may either assign you to a default (potentially higher) rate tier or decline to offer you a quote. Your consent is always required under Canadian privacy law.
Q: Will a bankruptcy affect my auto insurance?
A: A bankruptcy can impact your insurance score in provinces where credit-based scoring is used, potentially resulting in higher premiums. However, you can still get coverage, and as the bankruptcy ages (it remains on your credit report for six to seven years), its impact on your premiums should diminish.
Q: Does improving my credit lower my auto insurance?
A: In provinces where credit-based scoring is used, improving your credit score can lead to lower premiums at renewal. It is worth asking your insurer to re-evaluate your premium after significant credit improvement.
Q: Is it worth switching insurers to get a better rate with bad credit?
A: Absolutely. Different insurers weigh credit differently in their pricing models. An insurer that heavily penalizes poor credit might charge you far more than one that gives credit minimal weight. Shopping around is the single most effective strategy for finding affordable coverage.
Q: Do claims affect my credit score?
A: No. Auto insurance claims do not appear on your credit report and do not directly affect your credit score. Claims are tracked in separate insurance databases and affect your future insurance premiums, not your credit.
Q: Can my auto insurance premium change mid-policy because of a credit change?
A: No. Your premium is set at the start of your policy term and cannot be changed mid-term based on credit fluctuations. However, your credit score at the time of renewal can affect your new premium.
Final Thoughts: Taking Control of Your Auto Insurance Costs
The connection between credit scores and auto insurance in Canada is real but manageable. While it may seem unfair that your financial history affects your car insurance premiums, understanding the system empowers you to take action.
If you live in a province with public auto insurance, your credit score has no bearing on your basic coverage — a significant advantage for those with less-than-perfect credit. If you live in a province with private insurance, there are proven strategies to minimize the impact of bad credit on your premiums: shop aggressively, work with a broker, consider telematics programs, and focus on improving your credit over time.
Remember that credit is just one factor among many in auto insurance pricing. Your driving record, vehicle choice, location, and coverage levels all play important roles. By addressing all of these factors strategically, you can find affordable coverage that meets your needs, regardless of your credit situation.
Most importantly, do not let concerns about credit prevent you from getting the auto insurance you need. Every Canadian driver is entitled to coverage, and there are resources available — from brokers to the Facility Association — to ensure you are never left without it.
Your credit score is not permanent, and neither is its impact on your auto insurance premiums. Every positive step you take to improve your credit — from paying bills on time to reducing debt — brings you closer to lower premiums and better financial health overall.
Join 10,000+ Canadians who started their credit journey with Credit Resources.
GET STARTED NOWRelated Canadian Credit Guides
- Multi-Currency Banking in Canada: Managing Money Across Borders
- Canadian Banking Ombudsman: How OBSI Handles Consumer Complaints
- How to Open a Bank Account in Canada With No ID or Credit
- Pet Insurance in Canada: Coverage, Costs and Credit Impact (2026)
- Contactless Payment and Credit in Canada: Tap, Apple Pay & Google Pay
Start Understanding Your Credit Today
Join 10,000+ Canadians who took control of their financial future.
GET STARTED NOW