Canadian Bankruptcy Alternatives for Small Business Owners: BIA Division I & II Proposals

Mar 20, 202620 min read

When Your Small Business Is Struggling: Understanding Your Options Beyond Bankruptcy

For Canadian small business owners facing insurmountable debt, the word “bankruptcy” often feels like the only option — and the most terrifying one. The reality is that Canadian insolvency law provides several powerful alternatives to bankruptcy that can allow you to restructure your debts, keep your business operating, and emerge financially stronger. Chief among these alternatives are Division I and Division II (Consumer) Proposals under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA).

The Canadian Insolvency Landscape: Where Proposals Fit

Before diving into the specifics of BIA proposals, it is essential to understand where they sit within Canada’s insolvency framework. Canadian insolvency law provides several distinct paths for individuals and businesses in financial distress:

Option	Best For	Debt Limit	Key Feature	Credit Report Impact
Division II Proposal (Consumer Proposal)	Sole proprietors with debts under $250,000	$250,000 (excl. mortgage)	Simplified process, lower cost	R7 rating, 3 years after completion
Division I Proposal	Businesses/individuals with debts over $250,000	No limit	Flexible, creditor classes, complex restructuring	R7 rating, 3 years after completion
Bankruptcy	Those with no viable restructuring option	No limit	Full discharge of eligible debts	R9 rating, 6–7 years (first bankruptcy)
CCAA (Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act)	Large corporations	Debts over $5 million	Court-supervised restructuring	Varies
Informal Debt Settlement	Those with few creditors	No limit	Negotiated directly, no legal process	Varies by creditor reporting

Important Distinction: Personal vs. Corporate Insolvency

If your business is incorporated (Ltd., Inc., or Corp.), your personal assets and business assets are generally separate. A corporate bankruptcy does not automatically mean personal bankruptcy. However, if you have personally guaranteed business debts — which most Canadian small business owners have — those guarantees follow you personally. Understanding this distinction is critical when evaluating your options.

Division II Proposals (Consumer Proposals): The Most Common Path

A Division II Proposal, commonly called a Consumer Proposal, is the most frequently used formal insolvency alternative in Canada. Despite the name “consumer,” it is widely used by sole proprietors, independent contractors, freelancers, and small business owners whose total debts (excluding any mortgage on their principal residence) do not exceed $250,000.

How a Consumer Proposal Works

A Consumer Proposal is a legally binding agreement between you and your creditors, administered by a Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT). You offer to pay your creditors a portion of what you owe — typically 20% to 50% of the total debt — over a period of up to five years. If your creditors accept, you are legally released from the remaining debt upon completion of the proposal.

Initial Consultation with a Licensed Insolvency Trustee

The process begins with a free, confidential consultation with an LIT. In Canada, only Licensed Insolvency Trustees can administer Consumer Proposals — not debt consultants, credit counsellors, or lawyers (though lawyers may refer you to an LIT). During this consultation, the LIT will review your complete financial situation, including personal and business debts, assets, income, and expenses. Major LIT firms in Canada include MNP Ltd., BDO Canada, Grant Thornton, and numerous independent practitioners.

Financial Assessment and Proposal Design

The LIT will assess what your creditors would receive in a bankruptcy scenario — this is the floor for your proposal, as creditors must receive at least as much as they would in bankruptcy. The LIT then designs a proposal that offers creditors more than they would receive in bankruptcy while remaining affordable for you. For example, if bankruptcy would yield creditors 15 cents on the dollar, your proposal might offer 30 cents on the dollar over 5 years.

Filing the Proposal

Once you and the LIT agree on terms, the proposal is filed with the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy (OSB). This filing immediately triggers a stay of proceedings — a legal protection that stops all creditor actions, including lawsuits, wage garnishments, and collection calls. This stay is one of the most powerful benefits of a formal proposal.

Creditor Voting

Creditors have 45 days to accept or reject the proposal. Each creditor votes according to the dollar value of their claim. For the proposal to pass, creditors representing a majority in dollar value must vote in favour. If fewer than 25% of creditors (by dollar value) request a meeting of creditors, the proposal is deemed accepted. In practice, most well-designed Consumer Proposals are accepted without a formal meeting.

Court Approval

Once accepted by creditors, the proposal is submitted to the court for approval. The court will approve the proposal unless it finds the terms are not reasonable or not made in good faith. Court rejection is rare for Consumer Proposals.

Making Payments and Fulfilling Obligations

You make your agreed-upon payments to the LIT, who distributes them to creditors. You must also attend two financial counselling sessions (mandatory under the BIA). These sessions cover budgeting, money management, and rebuilding credit — valuable knowledge for small business owners looking to avoid future financial distress.

“

In my 18 years of practice, I have seen thousands of small business owners assume that bankruptcy is their only option. In the vast majority of cases, a Consumer Proposal provides a better outcome — they keep their assets, pay less overall, and maintain their dignity. The key is seeking professional advice early, before the situation becomes truly desperate.

— Jennifer Walsh

Advantages of a Consumer Proposal for Small Business Owners

Keep your assets: Unlike bankruptcy, a Consumer Proposal does not require you to surrender assets. Your home, vehicle, tools, and business equipment are protected.
Reduced debt: Most Consumer Proposals settle debts for 20%–50% of the total owed. On $100,000 of debt, this could mean paying $20,000–$50,000 instead of the full amount.
Fixed payments: Your monthly payment is fixed for the duration of the proposal, regardless of changes in your income. If your business income increases, you keep the extra.
Stay of proceedings: Immediate legal protection from creditors upon filing.
Less severe credit impact: A Consumer Proposal results in an R7 rating (vs. R9 for bankruptcy) and is removed from your credit report 3 years after completion (vs. 6-7 years for bankruptcy).
No surplus income payments: In bankruptcy, if your income exceeds a threshold set by the OSB, you must pay a portion of the surplus to your creditors. Consumer Proposals have no such requirement.

Tax Implications of Consumer Proposals

When a creditor forgives debt through a Consumer Proposal, the CRA may consider the forgiven amount as income. For example, if you owed $80,000 and your proposal settles for $30,000, the forgiven $50,000 could potentially be added to your taxable income. However, there are exceptions and nuances — particularly for insolvent taxpayers. Always consult with a tax professional who understands insolvency taxation. Additionally, CRA debts (back taxes, GST/HST owing) can be included in a Consumer Proposal, which is a significant advantage over informal settlement.

Division I Proposals: For Larger Business Debts

When a small business owner’s debts exceed $250,000 (excluding mortgage on principal residence), or when the business is incorporated, a Division I Proposal becomes the appropriate vehicle. Division I Proposals are more complex, more flexible, and carry higher stakes than Consumer Proposals.

Key Differences Between Division I and Division II Proposals

Feature	Division I Proposal	Division II (Consumer) Proposal
Debt limit	No limit	$250,000 (excl. mortgage)
Available to corporations	Yes	No (individuals only)
Creditor classes	Can create multiple classes (secured, unsecured, preferred)	Single class (unsecured only)
Consequence of rejection	Automatic bankruptcy	No automatic bankruptcy
Cost	Higher (LIT fees, legal costs)	Lower (fees set by tariff)
Creditor meeting	Mandatory	Only if requested by 25%+ of creditors
Court approval	Always required, more scrutiny	Required but typically routine
Maximum duration	No fixed limit (typically 3–5 years)	Maximum 5 years

The Biggest Risk of Division I Proposals

The most critical difference between Division I and Division II Proposals is what happens if the proposal is rejected by creditors. If creditors vote against a Division I Proposal, you are automatically deemed bankrupt. There is no second chance, no opportunity to file a different proposal. This makes the design and negotiation of a Division I Proposal extremely high-stakes. You must work with an experienced LIT and potentially legal counsel to ensure your proposal has a strong chance of acceptance before filing.

When Division I Proposals Make Sense for Small Businesses

Division I Proposals are particularly valuable in the following situations:

Incorporated businesses with viable operations: If your business is generating revenue but is crushed by debt accumulated during difficult times, a Division I Proposal can restructure the debt while keeping the business running.
Businesses with multiple creditor types: Division I Proposals allow you to create different classes of creditors (secured lenders, unsecured trade creditors, government agencies) and offer different terms to each class.
Real estate-related businesses: Construction companies, developers, and property management firms often have complex debt structures that require the flexibility of a Division I Proposal.
Businesses seeking to preserve key contracts: A Division I Proposal can be structured to maintain critical supplier relationships and customer contracts that would be lost in bankruptcy.

Credit Resources Team — Expert Note

Division I Proposals require careful legal strategy. Unlike Consumer Proposals, you are dealing with sophisticated creditors — banks, institutional lenders, the CRA — who will scrutinize every aspect of your proposal. The creditor meeting is mandatory and can be contentious. I always recommend that small business owners retain both an experienced LIT and an insolvency lawyer when pursuing a Division I Proposal. The cost of professional representation is far outweighed by the potential consequences of a rejected proposal.

Real-World Scenarios: How BIA Proposals Work in Practice

Scenario 1: The Restaurant Owner (Consumer Proposal)

Priya operates a small restaurant in Mississauga, Ontario, as a sole proprietor. After three years of declining revenue and personal credit card debt accumulated to keep the restaurant afloat, she owes $180,000 in unsecured debt (credit cards, lines of credit, supplier accounts, and CRA arrears for unremitted HST).

Her LIT determines that in bankruptcy, creditors would receive approximately $15,000 (from surplus income payments over 21 months). Priya’s Consumer Proposal offers $45,000, paid at $750/month over 60 months. This represents 25 cents on the dollar — significantly more than the bankruptcy dividend.

The proposal is accepted without a creditor meeting. Priya keeps her restaurant equipment, her personal vehicle, and her home. After 5 years of payments, the remaining $135,000 in debt is legally forgiven.

Scenario 2: The Construction Company (Division I Proposal)

BuildRight Inc., a small construction company in Edmonton, Alberta, has $1.2 million in debts including $400,000 to its bank (secured by equipment), $600,000 to trade suppliers, and $200,000 to the CRA. The company has ongoing projects worth $2 million in revenue over the next 18 months.

A Division I Proposal creates two creditor classes: secured (the bank) and unsecured (suppliers and CRA). The bank is offered full repayment over 36 months with reduced interest. Unsecured creditors are offered 40 cents on the dollar over 48 months. The proposal is accepted because creditors recognize they will receive more than in a liquidation bankruptcy, and the ongoing projects generate revenue to fund the proposal payments.

The Role of Licensed Insolvency Trustees

In Canada, Licensed Insolvency Trustees are the only professionals authorized to administer BIA proposals and bankruptcies. They are licensed by the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy (a federal government agency) and are subject to strict regulatory oversight.

How to Choose an LIT

Look for experience with small businesses: Not all LITs have equal experience with business-related proposals. Ask specifically about their experience with businesses in your industry.
Check their standing: Verify their licence through the OSB’s searchable directory at ic.gc.ca.
Compare fees: For Consumer Proposals, LIT fees are set by a government-regulated tariff and are paid from your proposal payments (not in addition to them). For Division I Proposals, fees are more variable and should be discussed upfront.
Seek referrals: Ask your accountant, lawyer, or business advisor for recommendations. Industry associations like the Canadian Association of Insolvency and Restructuring Professionals (CAIRP) can also help.

Beware of Debt Consultants and Debt Settlement Companies

In Canada, only Licensed Insolvency Trustees can file Consumer Proposals and Division I Proposals. Some debt settlement companies and “debt consultants” charge upfront fees, promising to negotiate with creditors on your behalf — but they cannot provide the legal protections of a formal BIA proposal. The FCAC and provincial consumer protection agencies have issued warnings about these companies. Always verify that you are working with a licensed professional by checking the OSB directory.

Alternatives to BIA Proposals

Before pursuing a formal BIA proposal, consider whether less formal alternatives might work for your situation:

Informal Debt Restructuring

If you have a small number of creditors and a reasonable offer, you may be able to negotiate directly (or through a credit counsellor) without the formal BIA process. This avoids the credit report notation of a formal proposal but lacks legal protections.

Debt Consolidation Loans

If your credit score is still reasonable (650+), a debt consolidation loan from a bank or credit union might allow you to combine multiple debts into a single lower-interest payment. This is often the best option if you can qualify and your total debt is manageable. For more on this approach, see our guide on debt consolidation options in Canada.

Credit Counselling and Debt Management Programs

Non-profit credit counselling agencies (such as those accredited by Credit Counselling Canada) offer Debt Management Programs (DMPs) where they negotiate reduced interest rates with your creditors. You repay 100% of the principal over 4–5 years, but with reduced or eliminated interest. DMPs result in an R7 credit rating, similar to a Consumer Proposal, but require you to repay the full principal amount.

Orderly Payment of Debts (OPD)

Available in Alberta, Saskatchewan, Nova Scotia, and Prince Edward Island, OPD is a court-ordered program that consolidates unsecured debts and sets the interest rate at 5%. You repay 100% of the principal plus 5% interest over up to 3 years. This program is administered through provincial government offices.

Impact on Your Credit and Future Borrowing

Understanding the credit implications of a BIA proposal is crucial for small business owners who will need credit in the future — whether for personal purchases or business operations.

During the Proposal

A notation appears on your credit report with Equifax Canada and TransUnion Canada indicating that you have filed a proposal.
Your accounts included in the proposal are rated R7 (indicating you are making payments through a third-party arrangement).
You can still obtain credit during the proposal, but you must disclose the proposal to any lender from whom you seek credit of $1,000 or more.
Obtaining new credit during a proposal is difficult but not impossible — secured credit cards and some alternative lenders will work with proposal filers.

After Completion

The proposal notation remains on your Equifax Canada report for 3 years after completion and on your TransUnion Canada report for 3 years after completion.
Active credit rebuilding should begin as soon as possible after filing — do not wait until the proposal is completed.
Secured credit cards, small installment loans, and Canadian Tire or Capital One cards are common rebuilding tools.

Time a Consumer Proposal notation remains on your Canadian credit report after completion

For detailed strategies on rebuilding credit after a proposal, read our comprehensive guide on rebuilding credit after a consumer proposal.

Getting a Mortgage After a Proposal

One of the biggest concerns for small business owners is whether they can qualify for a mortgage after a BIA proposal. The answer is yes, but with conditions:

Most A-lenders (Big Five banks) require at least 2 years of re-established credit after the proposal is completed and discharged.
B-lenders and private lenders may approve mortgages sooner but at higher interest rates.
A minimum 10%–20% down payment is typically required.
You will need to demonstrate stable income and responsible credit behaviour since the proposal.

“

I have helped dozens of clients obtain mortgages after Consumer Proposals. The key is starting to rebuild credit immediately — get a secured credit card, make every payment on time, and keep utilization low. Within 2–3 years of completing their proposal, many of my clients qualify for competitive mortgage rates from mainstream lenders.

— Angela Foster

Protecting Your Business During the Proposal Process

For small business owners who want to continue operating during and after a BIA proposal, there are several strategic considerations:

Supplier Relationships

If suppliers are included in your proposal, they may be reluctant to continue extending credit. Strategies to manage this include:

Negotiating cash-on-delivery terms with key suppliers before filing
Establishing relationships with alternative suppliers not affected by the proposal
Using the LIT as an intermediary to explain the proposal’s benefits to suppliers (they receive more than in bankruptcy)

Business Licences and Professional Certifications

In most Canadian provinces, filing a BIA proposal does not affect your business licence or professional certification. However, certain professions (real estate agents, insurance brokers, some financial professionals) may have regulatory requirements related to insolvency. Check with your provincial regulatory body before filing.

Employee Obligations

If you have employees, their wages and vacation pay are given priority status in a BIA proposal. The Wage Earner Protection Program (WEPP), administered by Service Canada, provides limited protection for employee wages owed at the time of an insolvency filing — up to approximately $8,500 per employee.

Strategic Timing of Your Proposal Filing

The timing of your proposal filing can significantly affect the outcome. Consider filing after the peak season for your business (when you can demonstrate strong revenue), after resolving any outstanding CRA audits (which could increase your total debt), and before any creditors obtain judgments that could complicate the process. Your LIT can advise on optimal timing based on your specific circumstances.

CRA Debts and BIA Proposals

For many Canadian small business owners, Canada Revenue Agency debts are the largest single obligation. This includes income tax arrears, unremitted GST/HST, payroll source deductions, and penalties and interest.

How the CRA Votes on Proposals

The CRA is one of the most sophisticated creditors in any BIA proposal. They have detailed guidelines for evaluating and voting on proposals:

The CRA generally requires proposals to offer at least as much as bankruptcy would yield, plus a reasonable premium.
For proposals involving trust debts (unremitted GST/HST and payroll source deductions), the CRA may require higher recovery rates.
The CRA can and does vote against proposals it considers insufficient — their vote can make or break your proposal if they hold a large portion of your total debt.

Credit Resources Team — Expert Note

One of the most common mistakes I see is small business owners who assume all CRA debts are treated equally in a proposal. They are not. Unremitted GST/HST and payroll source deductions are trust debts — money you collected on behalf of the government. While these can be included in a BIA proposal, the CRA often views them more severely and may require a higher recovery rate. It is essential to quantify and categorize all CRA debts accurately before designing your proposal.

Costs of Filing a BIA Proposal

Consumer Proposal Costs

The cost of a Consumer Proposal is regulated by the BIA tariff. The LIT’s fees are calculated as a percentage of the proposal payments and are paid from those payments — you do not pay LIT fees on top of your proposal payments. Typically, the LIT receives approximately 20% of the proposal payments plus a small filing fee.

Division I Proposal Costs

Division I Proposal costs are more variable and can range from $5,000 to $50,000 or more, depending on the complexity of the business, the number of creditors, and the amount of work required. These costs include LIT fees, legal fees, filing fees, and potentially the cost of an independent financial review.

Life After a Proposal: Rebuilding for the Future

Completing a BIA proposal is not the end of your financial journey — it’s a fresh start. Here’s how to make the most of it:

Obtain Your Credit Reports

Within 30 days of completing your proposal, obtain your credit reports from both Equifax Canada and TransUnion Canada. Verify that all accounts included in the proposal are correctly noted as “included in proposal” and that the completion date is accurately recorded. Dispute any errors immediately.

Get a Secured Credit Card

A secured credit card (where you provide a cash deposit as collateral) is the most reliable way to begin rebuilding credit. Canadian options include Home Trust Secured Visa, Capital One Secured Mastercard, and Refresh Financial Secured Visa. Use the card for small regular purchases and pay the balance in full each month.

Apply for a Credit-Building Loan

Products like Refresh Financial’s credit-builder loan are designed specifically for Canadians rebuilding credit. You make payments into a savings account, and the lender reports your positive payment history to the credit bureaus. After the loan term, you receive the saved funds minus fees.

Rebuild Business Credit Separately

If you plan to continue operating a business, establish business credit independently of your personal credit. Register with Dun & Bradstreet Canada to obtain a DUNS number, open business accounts with suppliers who report to business credit bureaus, and maintain impeccable payment history.

Monitor Your Progress

Use free credit monitoring tools available through services like Borrowell (Equifax) or Credit Karma (TransUnion) to track your score improvement. Most people see significant credit score improvement within 12–18 months of actively rebuilding after a proposal.

Ready to Take Control of Your Credit?

Join 10,000+ Canadians who started their credit journey with Credit Resources.

GET STARTED NOW

No Hard Check Cancel Anytime $20/week

Frequently Asked Questions About BIA Proposals

Yes. One of the primary advantages of a Consumer Proposal over bankruptcy is that you keep all your assets, including your home. Your mortgage is not affected by the proposal (as long as you continue making mortgage payments). The equity in your home is considered when calculating what creditors would receive in bankruptcy, which influences the minimum your proposal must offer, but you do not lose your home.

The maximum term for a Consumer Proposal is 60 months (5 years). However, you can pay it off faster without penalty. Some proposals are completed in as little as 12–24 months. There is no advantage to taking longer than necessary — the sooner you complete the proposal, the sooner the 3-year clock starts on the credit report notation.

Yes. If you miss three monthly payments (or fall behind by a total amount equal to three payments), your Consumer Proposal is automatically annulled — meaning it is cancelled, and you are back to owing the full original debt. If you anticipate difficulty making payments, contact your LIT immediately. Your proposal terms can often be amended to accommodate temporary financial difficulties.

While not legally required, a lawyer is strongly recommended for Division I Proposals due to the complexity of the process and the automatic bankruptcy consequence if the proposal is rejected. An insolvency lawyer can help negotiate with creditors, prepare for the creditor meeting, and navigate court approval. For Consumer Proposals, a lawyer is generally not necessary as the LIT handles the entire process.

Absolutely. BIA proposals are well-suited to self-employed Canadians and those with irregular income. For Consumer Proposals, your payments are fixed regardless of income fluctuations. Your LIT will design the proposal payments based on your average income and ability to pay. For more strategies on managing credit with irregular income, see our guide on credit building for commission-based workers.

Conclusion: Taking Control of Your Financial Future

Financial distress is not a character flaw — it is a business reality that millions of Canadian small business owners face. The Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act provides powerful tools through Division I and Division II Proposals that allow you to restructure your debts, protect your assets, and preserve your business while offering creditors a fair resolution.

The most important step is also the hardest: acknowledging the problem and seeking professional help. A free consultation with a Licensed Insolvency Trustee carries no obligation and no judgment. It simply provides you with information about your options so you can make an informed decision.

Key Takeaways

Whether you choose a Consumer Proposal, a Division I Proposal, or another debt solution entirely, the critical factor is acting before your situation deteriorates further. Early intervention provides more options, better outcomes, and less stress. If your small business is struggling with debt, schedule a free consultation with a Licensed Insolvency Trustee today — it may be the most important business decision you make.

Remember: every year, tens of thousands of Canadians use BIA proposals to resolve their debts and start fresh. You are not alone, and the system is designed to help you. Take the first step.

For more information on managing debt and rebuilding credit in Canada, explore our guides on understanding Canadian credit scores and financial planning for Canadians managing multiple financial responsibilities.

Canadian Bankruptcy Alternatives for Small Business Owners: BIA Division I & II Proposals